In the Roblox game Steal a Brainrot, a heated community debate rages over whether the OG Skibidi Toilet deserves its top-tier rarity label. Released in the December 2025 Skibidi update, this brainrot pet clashes with older OGs from the game's pre-2020 days. Many players insist that "true OG" status should hinge on age, not just performance, accusing developers of inflating rarity for newer items buy Steal a Brainrot Brainrots.
Developers base OG classification on practical metrics like income generation—$350 million per second for Skibidi Toilet—along with its $350 billion sell value and unique traits, such as staring animation multipliers. This approach ignores historical roots, prompting backlash through YouTube rants, Discord polls where over 60% favor age-based tiers, and high-value trades equivalent to 2 billion per second. Critics label it the "worst OG" since it trails powerhouses like Strawberry Elephant at 550 million per second or Meowl at 450 million per second.
OG rarity emphasizes economic strength over longevity. Skibidi Toilet's base form ranks 11th among brainrots earning over 100 million per second, with boosts from events like Admin Abuses. While legacy OGs from over a decade ago carry nostalgia, they often underperform in rebirth-scaled income, according to wikis and guides. No age rules apply officially; updates like Skibidi introduce "modern OGs" to refresh the meta.
Community views split sharply. Supporters argue it matches elite earners and behaves identically to veterans on conveyors or during steals in events like Taco Tuesday. Opponents decry its 2023 origins as disqualifying, pushing for a "Legacy OG" category or demotion to God or Secret rarity. Neutrals point out that trading values prioritize power over purity, and free-to-play conveyor odds under 1% make stealing the real path forward regardless.
Events such as Admin Abuses or Skibidi spawns temporarily spike drops across all OGs, sidelining age arguments amid the grind. Stealing stays dominant: slip in with invisibility cloaks or clones, grab with E, and escape via trap loops—the rarity tag changes nothing. Future patches could tweak balances through income nerfs or new ancients.
Ultimately, the controversy highlights Steal a Brainrot's evolving economy, where raw power often trumps tradition, keeping players hooked on steals and trades alike.
